Increasing Case Acceptance Through Hygienist-Led Conversations

By: Clayton Davis, DDS
This topic originally appeared on PankeyGram.org. Dr. Davis granted permission for igniteDDS to share with our readers.

What if your hygiene team could help patients commit to treatment—before you even walk into the room?
15 years ago, while visiting New York City, I dropped by a high-performing dental practice I’d heard a lot about. These two dentists were producing cosmetic and restorative dentistry at levels far above mine, and I wanted to learn their secret.

Their office looked a lot like mine—modest furnishings, standard equipment, friendly staff. But then, during my visit, something eye-opening happened.

The hygienist knocked on the door and casually reminded the doctor that a patient who had once postponed veneers due to his daughter’s college graduation was now ready to revisit treatment—and had already been scheduled to start.

I was floored. She had done exactly what I had always hoped my hygiene team would do: move patients forward in their treatment journey— naturally, without the doctor having to initiate the conversation.

When I returned to my practice, I asked myself:

How can I create this same proactive culture in my hygiene department?

A Simple Scorecard That Works

One simple solution came to mind: gamify the behavior.

I created a score sheet we now call “Hygiene Points.” The goal wasn’t pressure—it was awareness and growth. Each hygienist began scoring their efforts after every hygiene appointment.

Here’s how it works:

  • Score 1: I reintroduce treatment and the patient schedules.
  • Score 2: The hygienist identifies an issue that needs monitoring.
  • Score 3: I diagnose something new, and the patient schedules.
  • Score 4: The hygienist gets the previously discussed treatment scheduled without me.
  • Score 5: The hygienist takes an intraoral photo and flags it for me; I confirm the concern, and the patient schedules.
  • Score 6: The hygienist gets a patient to schedule treatment before I enter the room.

At first, we simply tracked our baseline. But then, something amazing happened. The hygiene team’s competitive instincts kicked in. They wanted higher scores. Not for prizes or bonuses—just for the professional satisfaction of doing better.

Within months, we saw a noticeable uptick in scheduled treatment coming directly from hygiene appointments. After two years, our restorative production had increased, and case acceptance had improved dramatically—all without adding any new marketing or expensive equipment.

Key Takeaway

Sometimes, the biggest impact comes from the simplest tools. If you want to train your hygiene team to confidently support case acceptance, explore comprehensive learning education at The Pankey Institute for effective hygiene handoffs, designed to elevate both the patient conversation and the clinical result.

Categories

Testimonials

Alyse Berta
Dawn, thank you for the great advice and guidance you’ve shared as we work on improving our practice's efficiency. I truly appreciate your...
Read More
Dawn, thank you for the great advice and guidance you’ve shared as we work on improving our practice's efficiency. I truly appreciate your support and the time you’ve taken to help us move forward in a more streamlined and effective way. Your insight has been incredibly valuable and is helping us make meaningful progress.
Alyse Berta
Dani S.

Dani S.

IGNITEDDS has made a real difference in our practice and in my role as office manager. The support I’ve received has...
Read More

Dani S.

IGNITEDDS has made a real difference in our practice and in my role as office manager. The support I’ve received has helped me grow with more confidence and clarity, and our systems and leadership have improved because of it. Dawn has been an incredible support to me personally, always present, approachable, and truly invested in our success. I never feel alone when challenges come up, and that level of guidance and encouragement has been invaluable. IGNITEDDS doesn’t just support practices; they support the people behind them.
Dani S.
Eva B.

Eva B.

Working with IGNITEDDS Coaching has been such a great experience! Having David as a dentist makes a huge difference. He truly...
Read More

Eva B.

Working with IGNITEDDS Coaching has been such a great experience! Having David as a dentist makes a huge difference. He truly understands the day-to-day challenges we face in practice. His insight makes their guidance practical, relevant, and easy to implement. Working alongside Dawn has been such a gift! She’s always available to answer questions, talk through ideas, and help us find the right solutions. Her advice is thoughtful, effective, and supportive. It hasn’t just helped me, it’s positively impacted our entire team and elevated our patient experience. I’m incredibly grateful to partner with Ignite as we continue to grow, strengthen our team, and serve our patients at a higher level.
Eva B.
Kylinn Tucker, RDH

Kylinn Tucker, RDH

I had an amazing experience with the IGNITEDDS Coaching program. Especially since I am a new hygienist, everything...
Read More

Kylinn Tucker, RDH

I had an amazing experience with the IGNITEDDS Coaching program. Especially since I am a new hygienist, everything you guys shared was so helpful. It’s evident that you guys prioritize each individual team member of a dental office and do everything you can to make the environment and schedule run as smoothly and efficiently as possible. I learned so much about treatment planning, Dentrix, scheduling, teamwork, and overall ways to continue improving as a new grad. I wish every dental office had the opportunity to complete this program.
Kylinn Tucker, RDH
Dr Ben Truong

Dr. Ben Truong

It was great working with a team to help bring out the best in each of us. Our team is ...
Read More

Dr. Ben Truong

It was great working with a team to help bring out the best in each of us. Our team is small, but we work closely together to provide a great patient experience, while having fun at work as well! Your team was able to help us learn to work together, with each person having a vital role in providing care to the patient! Helping us all become streamlined and on the same page will help us become an even more successful practice!
Dr Ben Truong
Dr. Ronnetta Sartor

Dr. Ronnetta Sartor

The 90-Day Jump Start has been transformative for our office. Dawn and Dr. Rice guided us through implementing essential systems ...
Read More

Dr. Ronnetta Sartor

The 90-Day Jump Start has been transformative for our office. Dawn and Dr. Rice guided us through implementing essential systems and processes, from new patient calls to treatment planning and case acceptance. Their focus on patient care and team accountability has helped us create better structure, improve work/life balance, and stay aligned with our goals. In a short time, our practice has grown tremendously.
Dr. Ronnetta Sartor
Dr. Chandler Oldenburg

Dr. Chandler Oldenburg

IGNITEDDS has been truly transformative for our practice. Within just a few months, our accounts receivable collections increased by $30K, ...
Read More

Dr. Chandler Oldenburg

IGNITEDDS has been truly transformative for our practice. Within just a few months, our accounts receivable collections increased by $30K, and our operations became far more streamlined. Their clear procedures and policies gave our team structure and confidence, while their step-by-step ownership guidance addressed our specific challenges. Thanks to David and Dawn, we feel more organized, empowered, and aligned than ever before. I highly recommend IGNITEDDS to any practice ready to grow and strengthen its foundation.
Dr. Chandler Oldenburg
Dr. Layla Lohmann

Dr. Layla Lohmann

Working with Dr. David Rice through IGNITEDDS was a game-changer for our Doctor Development Program. We have a solid foundation ...
Read More

Dr. Layla Lohmann

Working with Dr. David Rice through IGNITEDDS was a game-changer for our Doctor Development Program. We have a solid foundation with our business content and organizational support, but Dr. Rice brought in the critical pieces that truly completed the puzzle. His seamless integration of dental expertise, vendor relationships, and mentorship made an undeniable impact.
Dr. Layla Lohmann
Dr. Brad Eller

Dr. Brad Eller

Dr. Rice brought fresh ideas and meaningful structure to our doctors and offices from day one. He leads every...
Read More

Dr. Brad Eller

Dr. Rice brought fresh ideas and meaningful structure to our doctors and offices from day one. He leads every discussion with knowledge, enthusiasm, empathy, and motivation that truly resonates. He challenged everyone to step outside their self-made boxes and sparked a renewed drive to grow and improve. His approach is humble, yet it’s clear he has discovered a better, more fulfilling way to live and lead. He inspires you to become a stronger version of yourself while embracing every opportunity. His realistic roadmap and focus on balancing success with personal happiness made our inaugural Catalyst program impactful.
Dr. Brad Eller
Dr. Andrew Le

Dr. Andrew Le

Dr. David Rice and IGNITEDDS is just what every young dentist needs! He is extremely helpful in both the clinical ...
Read More

Dr. Andrew Le

Dr. David Rice and IGNITEDDS is just what every young dentist needs! He is extremely helpful in both the clinical and business side of dentistry. His genuine kindness is contagious and he just makes you want to keep striving for the best.
Dr. Andrew Le

x

Join Us

Become a Preferred Partner

Join as a preferred partner to unlock growth, visibility, and strategic collaboration opportunities.

No Thanks